As the blog grows the comment moderation becomes quite a task. 10 good quality comments are lot better than 100 cheap comments. In the survey I conducted, I realised that most of you were upset about the quality/maturity of comments (thankfully, not so much of the articles!). I promised to regulate the comments/users but there is this thing called ‘time’ which I don’t have much and as a result, either I don’t get to read all comments or end up doing nothing about comments that need to be warned and users that need to be banned. Now, I’ve got a solution, that will never fail.
Yes, I’ve found a solution for comment moderation in BlueChampions. The name of the solution is Kafka. I met this guy on the internet few weeks back and after some deliberations we’ve agreed that he would be the comment moderator for BlueChampions. I’ve hired him (that is, I’m paying him) to be the comment moderator here for BlueChampions. Kafka lives in London but supports Dinamo Kiev and has vast experience (used to play, he says) and knowledge in football and also in website design and control. He has past experience in moderating websites (non-football), so he knows his way inside out.
My simple instructions to him are strictly no abuses or cheap insults against each other or Chelsea club, players, coaches, staff, owner and anything to do with Chelsea. Also no insults or defamation of anything related to Chelsea (c’mon, this is a Chelsea fan blog). That doesn’t mean we can shower Rafa Benitez with all the swear words that we know. Any comment that is of ‘cheap taste’ is to be put under moderation. Anyone making racist remarks will be dumped forever. This does not mean any ban on opposite views – other club fans such as SpanishFry, RedRanter etc have all posted comments and they are all there. It’s not about what you comment but how you comment. Allright, certain things are subjective, but I’ve decided to leave it to Kafka and I’m not planning to spend to anymore time on this.
I asked him about how he would deal with such things. He says he has his own methods – flags, period ban, IP nuke, no-comment ban, no-site ban, bot-ban, php controller and so many other techie stuff that my brain can’t handle. He also talked about something called progressive banning which means a first offence gets a 2-day ban and second one gets a 4-day ban and it keeps increasing with every offence. And yes, Kafka’s made it clear that I shouldnt come crying to him if he bans someone and I’m not fine with it. He has a job and he gets paid for it, so I’d respect his decisions. Why not, he saves me a lot of time and headaches!
If you wonder why I’m so excited, this blog has received about 9,500 spam comments so far in the last 12 months. It’s quite a job, this moderation thing and I’ve spent hours and hours for this. Hereafter, all that I’m going to do on this blog is to post articles, read comments and handle advertisements. Of course, I’m also looking for someone (I think I’ve found him) to handle the advertisements (my agent, you can say) and my email inbox as well, so that I can concentrate only on football. Wow, I’m loving that prospect.
Kafka has been observing this blog for more than a week now. He is also planning to come up with a comments policy! Beware, the big brother is watching you!



something i’ve been waiting for. in fact, everyone’s been waiting for. hope this will be a lot better place with strict moderation. i read somewhere that even the annoying comments posted online will amount to a cyber crime. so criminals around here lol. welldone.
very well done. if people like joeblue, md etc are not there, lots of visitors would come forward to post thier views and participate in discussions. above all, we can start having meaningful discussions. good effort.
oh yes
i stopped posting comments wating for such a move.
if the bigheaded, arrogant, empty vessels are not going to be around or if they are going to be given the stick, i’ll be back here having some good discussions with the great football/chelsea community that is formed here.
thatz really good…
Yay…
People – For all the efforts taken to regulate comments, I’m sure it would make lot of you happy. So, I thought you should be responding with more than 3 words! lol!
Hi Guys
We have a moderator now…thats nice..should bring about a lill more order here now…
Any of u guys saw the Euro qualifiers yesterday??..I was watching the england game..I think Joe and shaun on the wings worked well for England..Jose should try the same for chelsea if malouda isnt firing..
I am really beginning to like Micah richards..hes a great talent..if chelsea does break the bank for a defender, it should be for Micah richards..He would help to solve a lot of our defensive problems..
Sheva played for Ukraine yesterday..means hes fit..Jose should pick him against blackburn..pair him up front with Drogba..I feel Sheva is much better than pizzaro..
Thank God the internationals are over..we can get back to watching chelsea again..
Cmon Blues..Go Go Go
this blog will loose all its sheen….
manish you make good
arguments without any abuses or insults. whats ur problem mate
Great Going BC. well I never thought you had so many spam comments. Ofcourse I did not see any comments that were bad and offensive on here.
We hope to find Kafka usefull addition.
And as usual it is action time again this weekend. The one week gap seemed to be an era after we lost against Aston Villa…
Why am i having problems viewing his blog. Particularly because of the Ad on sentanta sports
Thanks for doing this. It was really a headache to see hate comments all along. Now I will comment, as a true Blue fan. :D
guys it seems an effort to have a comfort zone…only those comments which eulogies Chelsea…no detractors, no criticism…
certainly not. i’ve seen people criticise chelsea with a lot of sense and a level head on their shoulders. only the joeblue brand of bashing gets cheap and boring.
yeah great job bluechampion!
i really enjoy this blog and always check it out.
keep up the great work!
I guess some of you guys had trouble in viewing the blog, due to the flash file of the Setanta Sports advertisement. I’ve removed the ad now. It should all be fine.
Hey BC thats a really smart move it will only make bluechampions a better blog!!!! now we’ll be discussing chelseafc only:-p
What does this actually mean?!!no negatativity?or wat?i dont understand really wat u mean?like we cant say anything bad bout chelsea?
I’m not expected to give reasons but still let me tell ya. You have accumulated enough points to get yourself a short ban. You can criticise Chelsea as much as you want as long as you don’t insult, abuse or annoy others with derogatory language. If you find anything reportable, send it through contact form. I’m also handling the bluechampions mailbox now.
Ayyy.my god wat do we ave hea!come on BC!this dude is already intimidating people.this is a blog for christs sake.not some military camp or something.i really enjoyed coming to this blog.i actually find it better than the manutd blogs.(i am being honest).but this is too much.BC , u are making a mistake here.i want u to know that.kafka.please relax dude and be a bit chilled in this blog.it has a very friendly calm and fresh atmosphere.please do not spoil it as blogs are supposed to be fun.for fans of all clubs to enjoy debate.happy or sad.this is what us football fans need.so i am askin u not to spoil the terrific atmosphere we ave on this great blog.so kaf.who do u prefer united or chelsea?
I would just like to say that I’m happy that some criticism of Chelsea is still ‘allowed’ here, so long as it has solid foundations and isn’t based on petty insults. The fans should be the most important voice of the club and therefore they should be the first to decide when something is wrong. Don’t get me wrong; I absolutely adore supporting Chelsea, but sometimes our opinions do need to be expressed when it comes to the club’s methods of handling certain situations, on and off the pitch. When that starts being censored, we will simply become bystanders. The ‘Big Brother’ concept is probably one of my worst nightmares, so I’m glad to see that common sense is being used.
Now the solemn business is over with, I expect normal service to be resumed on Saturday with a 2-1 win. Hopefully, the rest of the Core Four will find their away games tricky as well. KTBFFH!
blue champion
wht on earth r u doin bro. yes ther need 2 b regulations. but uve taken it a step 2 far. its way 2 militant. and the gut u hav as a regulator, sound lyk he a general in the army.lol
by sayin no negativity towards chelski shld b limited, u r takin a majority of wht makes football great, >i.e corss rivalrly betweeen fans, and a difference of opinion, between the same fans..
Great initiative BC. Hot debate should in no way be affected by Big Brother (BB) but abuses and deliberate WUM would be dealt with. We can certainly criticize our coach and players without heaping abuses on them.
I think sheva will start this weekend together with Pizarro. I rate these two very highly and feel they should be encouraged. when both reach peak form, we should have no hesitation using the two with drogba in some variation of 4-3-3. What about this at some stage when these three strikers are at peak form.
——————————————–Cech—————————————-
—Belleti———————Riccy—————-Terry———————-A. cole
—————————————-Essien—————————————
——————Lampard————————————-Joe cole/Malouda
——-Drogba—————————–Pizarro————————-Sheva——
Giggs11egend & Football Guy:
Just a clarification. Blogs are all about opinions and a variety of them. I’m not trying to say anything against all things Chelsea FC goes into moderation. I’m only saying if it is in cheap taste, abusive and insulting. If there is a comment that supports Chelsea FC and is in ‘poor taste’ (hope you know what i mean), that will also be moderated.
See if you want to see the difference, I brought on Kafka for moderation but some of you don’t like the idea. But all your comments are published right here because they are all genuine opinions with no mindless abuse. Similarly, all comments are welcome as long as they are not in poor, cheap taste.
In another week’s time, you’ll see the difference. Remember, this moderation is something you asked for. That is, most of you. There are a lot of non-participative visitors, who remain in the shadows, in fear of comment-bullying. Let’s make it a fair and even playground for all. That’s it.
Giggs11egend – You’re a standing example of what this blog is all about. We all know that you’re a Man Utd fan and we welcome you and expect you to contribute and enjoy your stay here. That’s what I guess we’ve managed so far and that should continue. We welcome alternate views, if they are in the right spirit.
BC and KafKa… Moderation is all fine till you dont block genuine visitors and their comments into the site. Football is a game of passion and people should have a way to give their opinion unhindered. I am not against anyone saying anything against Chelsea… if there is no oppsoite opnion what is use of having one. I am not sure how Kafka is going to handle the comments posted by Anonymous users…